What makes a “good” movie?
I’m convinced that part of our opinions of the merits of a film are due to circumstances surrounding our movie-watching experiences, and not to the actual picture itself.
Expectations play a huge role in forming one’s opinions. Though I didn’t appreciate The Matrix when I first saw it on the big screen, I grew to love it and watched it voraciously prior to the releases of the second and third parts in the trilogy. Reloaded and Revolutions were disappointments to me; my expectations were too high and inhibited my enjoyment of the movies. On the other hand, I went to My Big Fat Greek Wedding expecting a fun, fluffy flick and I had a good fun, fluffy time.
Physical surroundings also play a role. I’ll always associate The Adventures of Baron Munchausen with these nasty tasting calzones from Sam’s Club I was eating while watching the movie. Coincidentally, Adventures also left a nasty taste in my mouth. Watch any slightly humorous movie with Charity and you can’t help but smile—the girl is a major movie laugher! We all know flicks like Dumb and Dumber and Tommy Boy are best watched in the right crowd, preferably late at night or accompanied by a few drinks (I mean KoolAid for you minors!). And we’ve all had bad movie-going experiences, ones where a kid kicks your chair through the entire two hour screening or someone with major b.o. sits right next to you. All these things can affect your opinion.
I bring all this up because I’ve had several discussions about movies in the past few days that have resulted in the following phrases: “What?!?! I HATED [or LOVED] that movie!!” …And I’ve been surprised by how different my perception of the film is from my friends’ opinions.
– After reading negative reviews, I ended up really liking Troy. My younger brother thought it was terrible. In fact, the scene I was most impressed by (Priam’s request in Achilles’ tent), Andrew thought was the worst. Huh.
– Though my psyche will forever be scarred, I thought The House of Sand and Fog was a decent movie. My friends Sarah and Dave thought it was just terrible. They also actually walked out of Cold Mountain out of boredom—and I really liked that show! Hmmm.
– I despised American Splendor. Everyone raved about this film so I suppose my expectations were quite high. Hated it. Only watched the whole thing because I kept hoping it would get better. Three friends in the past few days have mentioned how much they liked it. Ugh.
– Perhaps this goes without saying, but my parents and Jeremy’s parents hardly ever agree with us on “good” movies. One of my favorites, O Brother, Where Art Thou?, put my mother-in-law to sleep and made my mom roll her eyes. Ah well!
So who knows what makes a good movie? Academy Awards are given out year after year, and year after year people argue why one deserves the statuette and why another does not. I guess we can all just agree to amicably disagree.